Debating Morality: Can Ethics Exist Without God?
Episode Overview
The atheist caller questions the morality of Christianity, accusing it of spreading hate. Jon Steel argues that morality is grounded in God, while the caller believes in moral intuition. The discussion explores philosophical concepts like qualia and subjective vs objective morality. Jon challenges the caller to provide evidence or logical arguments against his faith. The episode highlights the complexities of debating faith and ethics.
If you're going to state that, then you must ground where this morality comes from.
In this thought-provoking episode of Big Jon Steel, Jon Steel engages in a deep and intense conversation with an atheist caller who questions the morality of Christianity. The discussion kicks off with the atheist accusing Jon of spreading hate through his religious beliefs. This sparks a spirited debate on the nature of morality, the definition of hate, and whether morality can exist without a divine being.
Jon passionately defends his stance that morality is grounded in God, while the atheist argues that moral intuition can serve as a basis for ethical decisions. The conversation takes several twists and turns, touching on philosophical concepts like qualia and the subjective versus objective nature of morality. Jon challenges the caller to provide concrete evidence or logical arguments that could make him reconsider his faith. The episode is a rollercoaster of intellectual exchanges, with moments of humour and tension.
Jon's unwavering faith and the atheist's persistent questioning create a dynamic dialogue that will leave you pondering your own beliefs. If you're interested in debates about faith, morality, and the human experience, this episode is a must-listen.